Teodoro Losing a Personal War with his Tantrums

Hiding behind an anonymous note that broke his cool, the man went haywire into hissy fits and started lunging attacks on China.

As they say it in the opera, “It ain’t over till the fat man sings.” (My apologies to the lady.)

An exchange occurred between Defense Secretary Gilbert Teodoro and whom he alleged was a Chinese delegate who handed hm a handwritten note on a piece of Lotte hotel stationery, while he was answering questions from the floor at the Seoul Defense Dialogue in South Korea.

Let me first present it in the raw before breaking it down into objective communication metrics, tactical intent, and the contrasting political lenses through which it is viewed:

(Teodoro in italics): “I have a note here, I think this is from China. May I read it – China’s position on the South China Sea arbitration is clear, consistent and firm. They have no position.

“The arbitration violates fundamental principles of international law. So what you signed UNCLOS…

“The so-called award is illegal, null and void.’ So say you, ‘and has no binding force’ because you don’t want to be subjected to UNCLOS.

“China neither accepts nor recognizes the award. Of course, because you lost…

“These are words slipped to me, and there is a legal principle called res ipsa loquitur, the thing speaks for itself.

“How can you deal with a country in an international forum, beyond the question asked to me? Disrespecting the organizers of this forum, how do you expect to deal with it civilly?

“I ask you the question, is this the right paper to post to me when I’m being asked a question on the floor? And how will you treat this kind of behavior?

“It not only disrespects (and) shows, if this is a Chinese position said to me, it not only disrespects international law.”

From the perspective of state-aligned critics or strict institutional diplomatics, Teodoro’s demeanor was combative or unvarnished. I would not be surprised if his proponents would paint his bluntness as a justified response to an unconventional ambush.

But directly calling out a member of the audience and using phrases like “show some shame” can be interpreted as emotional outburst. This sharp tone contributes to a hostile narrative that closes the door on diplomatic de-escalation or backchannel “resets”.  

His sullen attitude has no place in public especially outside of the Philippines. It borders on burn-out symptoms manifesting self-righteousness when confronted by opposition.

The Philippine defense secretary has often manifested to be onion-skinned which is why he prefers to appear only in forums that have controlled audiences and media interviews pre-arranged by his public relations agents.

This is precisely why he avoids the peanut gallery, a term grown from the cheapest, uppermost balcony seats in vaudeville theaters, from where spectators could afford cheap snacks like roasted peanuts, whose shells they occasionally toss down onto the performers or lower levels when displeased.

His decorum reflects a high-stakes rhetorical clash where blunt, emotional authenticity is deliberately feigned to hide weak positions and confused defense policy, that are more dogmatic than constructive.

Not everybody born with a silver spoon in his mouth or have reached high office can be presumed to have passing grades in GMRC – good manner and right conduct. Here is a book by a former ambassador recommended for public officials especially Cabinet members and legislators.

My two-cents worth

If I were advising Gilbert Teodoro, I would defend the Philippine legal position firmly but avoid turning the exchange into a personal confrontation with China.

My treatment follows:

“Thank you for your comment. I recognize that the note reflects China’s state policy. China is entitled to express its legal position, just as I, as Philippine defense secretary, am entitled to express ours.

“The Philippine position is straightforward: we participated in the arbitration under UNCLOS, and the tribunal rendered its award in 2016. The Philippines considers that award legally binding under the Convention.

“China, however, disagrees.

“Verily, we do not need to agree on the award in order to deal with one another. International relations require countries with profound disagreements to continue communicating, exercising restraint and avoiding actions that could lead to miscalculation.

“Our disagreement is with the position and conduct of the Chinese government—not with the Chinese people. We remain prepared to discuss our differences peacefully, professionally and in accordance with international law.

“With all due respects as guests of the Republic of Korea, I think our common obligation here is to maintain the dignity of our positions, regardless of the divergence of our points of view.

“Thank you.”

This format accomplishes five things simultaneously.

First, it doesn’t surrender the Philippine position nor soften his belief the award is binding under the UN Convention of the Law of the Sea.

Second, it avoids humiliating the Chinese delegation. Instead of implying disrespect, he phrases it as a criticism of conduct without turning it into a personal insult.

Third, it distinguishes the conduct of the Chinese government from the Chinese people. This is particularly important given the Philippines’ large Filipino-Chinese community and extensive people-to-people and economic relations with China.

Such would make it much harder for his remarks to be interpreted as Sinophobic or generally hostile towards Chinese people.

Fourth, it leaves the diplomatic door open. A defense secretary shouldn’t unnecessarily make tomorrow’s negotiation (on maritime incidents; fisheries; trade; tourism; overseas Filipino workers; consular issues; ASEAN; environmental concerns; crisis communication and the like), harder simply to win today’s rhetorical exchange.

Fifth, it makes the Philippines look stronger, not weaker.

There’s a great divide between acting aggressive and being authoritative.

Instead of appealing to civility and respect, I would have said, “We disagree with you profoundly, but we are confident enough in our legal position.”

Further, I would not have jumped into assuming a suspicious and incognito note came from China, just because it questions the Arbitral Award.

Nor will I use the legalese “res ipsa loquitur” in this context.

That Latin doctrine is principally associated with evidentiary inferences in negligence cases. It doesn’t establish the validity of the Philippines’ position regarding the South China Sea arbitration.

And I would not say “China lost”.

That kind of language is counterproductive.

Arguendo, a country that has been locked out from an international proceeding can still refuse to accept the judgment politically—as China has done.

The Philippine objective should be winning over China’s compliance through a peaceful and amicable discourse, not forcing China to publicly admit any defeat.

The ideal strategic posture before international publics is to frame the policy as: firm on law, calm in language, strong in confidence, open to dialogue. And most of all, protective of Philippine interests.

That combination would make it considerably harder for Beijing to portray the Philippines as the provocateur.

The Philippine government can be uncompromising about China’s conduct without allowing legitimate criticism of the Peoples Republic of China to spill over into hostility toward Chinese people or Filipino-Chinese communities.

In other words, Teodoro didn’t need to be less pro-Philippines. He has to be more disciplined in how he expressed it – a trait he has not developed despite the many public offices he has served.

If for whatever reason he can no longer hack it, he should leave the kitchen.

Reap what you sow

          Prof. Anna Rosario Malindog-Uy, a PhD economics candidate at the Institute of South-South Cooperation and Development at the Peking University, says “what goes around, comes around”.

She said perhaps this is also a useful lesson: disrespect does not suddenly become offensive only when you are the one receiving it.

The Philippine official has now become fair game to his detractors because instead of addressing the issues raised in past international open forums he has attended for the past year pertaining to Philippine policies and actions in the South China Seas, he has not only attacked the questioners as propagandists but claims they do not deserve an answer because China has a “trust deficit”.

This time, the beleaguered Teodoro ridiculously characterized a single act of an incognito as “coercion, bullying, and aggression” by China.

On the contrary as defense secretary, the professor said “If somebody hands you an objectionable note at an international forum, answer it firmly, professionally, and diplomatically.”

She added that there is no need to convert a piece of paper into a soap opera showing it as “Exhibit A” of wounded emotions: “diplomacy, after all, is supposedly about managing disagreements.”

Indeed, Teodoro’s single -issue theatrics must stop because the Philippine leadership whose credibility is at an all time low at negative 27% domestically, may have even gone lower internationally. We experienced a 91% drop in foreign direct investments for the month of July compared to that of last year.

His anti-China antics has not even improved the despicable 3% weight the local population renders “protecting Philippine sovereignty from foreign intervention” in the July 2026 Pulse Asia survey for most urgent national concerns.

 The endorsements we received for the 10th anniversary of the Arbitral Award has even just reduced to only 14 western-aligned countries, and significantly none from ASEAN.

Teodoro’s losing his temper in a multilateral forum has imposed more diplomatic costs at a time when his President is trying to improve the Philippines’ international reputation as a middle power.

Marcos’ next pitstop

This is most relevant because Ferdinand Marcos Jr. has accepted an invitation by Prime Minister Narendra Modi to attend the 18th BRICS Summit at New Delhi this weekend.

What face and issues will the Philippine president bring to that table? Will foreign dignitaries again be shown by foreign media to avoid shaking hands with Marcos or crossing his path?

BRICS is largely seen as offering emerging economies an alternative to Western-dominated alliances or institutions.

BRICS stands for Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa, the core members of the group. It’s expanded membership now stands at 11 after the inclusion of Egypt, Ethiopia, Indonesia, Iran, Saudi Arabia, and United Arab Emirates.

It currently engages 10 partner countries: Belarus, Bolivia, Kazakhstan, Cuba, Malaysia, Nigeria, Thailand, Uganda, Uzbekistan and Vietnam.

Manila sees the summit as a strategic opportunity to engage the major economies making up BRICS, which account for a major share of global output and trade.

But how will his defense secretary’s crass prestaging of our image abroad help Marcos at all?

Following Teodoro’s logic and pronouncements, all pro-China government officials must resign. Therefore, Go must stop what he is doing.

          China is one of the founders of BRICS.

          Teodoro represents the Philippine state. When he says China needs “basic decency” and should be ashamed, the world that is heavily influenced by China today, quates his principal Marcos as becoming confrontational rather than simply defending a legal position.

          This is a different and derogatory signal he is sending BRICS.

          Countries that depend economically on China, may privately agree with some Philippine concerns but hesitate to associate themselves publicly with an increasingly escalatory posture.

In ASEAN, ten other governments support neutrality, rejects Teodoro’s rhetoric that promotes regional polarization and refuses his zero-sum mentality of having to choose between Washington and Beijing.

Former neutral international audiences are starting to suggest that Teodoro’s anti-China position is a matter personality disorder rather than a principled legal dispute.

But when he says China needs to learn basic decency, he opens a can of worms because the next question is “over what”?

Asserting Philippine positions invites other nations to examine it in the light of international law.

Deputy Spokesperson of the Chinese Embassy Guo Wei clears the air:

“China’s position has always been clear on the so-called ‘South China Sea arbitration’.

“The Philippines unilaterally initiated the case, which is a distortion and abuse of the UNCLOS dispute settlement mechanism. It is the Philippine side who has violated UNCLOS and undermined its integrity and authority.

“What happened in Seoul and thereafter revealed two truths:

“First, an open and normal expression of views at a forum was exploited to launch a sweeping smear campaign against China and to sensationalize the issue.

“Allowing no room for any differing views in a public policy discussion, is precisely a manifestation of A LACK OF DECENCY.

“And when policy debate gives way to personal ridicule and mockery, that is what truly violates diplomatic decorum.

“Second, anti-China forces are really trying to seize every opportunity to attack and smear China with relentless determination.

“This reflects their UNRULY BEHAVIOR—opposing China at every turn, regardless of the issue. These figures want to lecture the international community about civilization? They should do so only after they learn how to be civilized themselves.

“We urge the certain individuals of the Philippines to cut the provocations and theatrics, and stop undermining China-Philippines relations and stability in the South China Sea.”

Behavioral pattern

Wow, did something just drop from the ceiling? What a Philippine loss of diplomatic altitude!

And this has not been happening in isolation.

Reuters recently reported that he labelled China’s responses to his attacks a “squid tactic”.

The defense secretary has also been conditioning public opinion urging greater scrutiny and vigilance over specific foreign-linked academic, language, and cultural exchange programs, warning that they could be utilized as “fronts for foreign malign influence.”

Witch-hunting for “spies” among Chinese students in Cagayan, for instance, has greatly reduced student tourism in the province.

A Mongolian foreign student enrolled in a flying school in Iba, Zambales, was also arrested for violating the law that prohibit taking photos and videos of locations close to a military installation.

The closest military facility to the municipal airport and a tourist resort that he shot, is Subic Base which is 75 kilometers and two hours away by land transport.

Teodoro’s pattern of loss of composure and lack of professionalism has so drained China’s patience and diplomatic restraint that on June 11, 2026, China sanctioned him and his family from entering mainland China, Hong Kong, and Macao. Chinese organizations, firms, and individuals have likewise been barred from engaging in any transactions, business dealings, or cooperative activities with them.

Actually, the sanction seemed tardy in addressing what is now surfacing as partisanship bordering on corruption, thus propelled by bad faith.

What is more disturbing on the ground is a new exposition of Teodoro’s vested interests in a scandal that has totally no connection to the South China Seas debates.

The defense secretary has not answered 16 questions posted to him in connection with his supervised raid on a steel factory in Tagoloan, Misamis Oriental where he caused the arrests of 69 Chinese workers, flew them in a military plane from Mindanao to Manila, hauled them in unhabitable immigration detention cells, only to be ordered released for lack of evidence some days after by the National Prosecution Service.

Chinese workers harassed despite legal documents, proper visas and working permits.

Steel factory ordered closed with more than 300 Filipino  workers displaced.

It later surfaced that this raid, together with other plants in Davao City and Pampanga province, were part of an industry feud between factories using fossil-fuel fired and those employing induction furnaces.

The Philippine Daily Tribune was vocal on cartelization alleging Benjamin Yao, chairman and CEO of SteelAsia that has established business dealings with the Department of National Defense, was a batchmate of Teodoro at Xavier School.

It revealed that SteelAsia employs fossil-fuel fired processes, and wants to yank out stiff competition through weaponization of law enforcement, instead of mobilizing government regulatory agencies. I mean if Yao has good intentions, I would advise him to lobby for better steel making policies, instead of relying on Teodoro’s imagined police powers. 

What is worse, is Teodoro has already been in pursuit of a certain Yang brothers in statements he issued last year, falsely accusing them of owning the raided Tagoloan facility, who he alleged, were involved in offshore gaming operations.

What became worst, was a few weeks after the raid, American soldiers attempted to enter and inspect the  steel factory, which the US Embassy subsequently passed on under the lame excuse of studying its possible use for forthcoming Balikatan military exercises, raising suspicions that Teodoro is brokering for the Deep State, the US military industrial complex.

Marcos may be using Teodoro for his Mutt-and-Jeff strategies balancing the sensitivities between the Chinese and the Americans, but it is at least obvious to me, that he picked the wrong alter-ego.

As his own aunt Gretchen Cojuangco advises:

“Anybody, but…Gibo!”

Read: https://asiancenturyph.com/2026/04/29/gibo-teodoro-the-most-promising-failure-in-philippine-politics/

 

Adolfo Quizon Paglinawan

is former diplomat who served as press attaché and spokesman of the Philippine Embassy in Washington DC and the Philippines’ Permanent Mission to the United Nations in New York from April 1986 to 1993. Presently, he is vice-president for internal affairs of the Asian Century Philippines Institute, a geopolitical analyst, author of books, columnist, a print and broadcast journalist, and a hobby-organic-farmer.

His best sellers, A Problem for Every Solution (2015), a characterization of factors affecting Philippine-China relations, and No Vaccine for a Virus called Racism (2020) a survey of international news attempting to tracing its origins, earned for him an international laureate in the Awards for the Promotion of Philippine-China Understanding in 2021. His third book, The Poverty of Power is now available – a historiography of controversial issues of spanning 36 years leading to the Demise of the Edsa Revolution and the Forthcoming Rise of a Philippine Phoenix.

Today he is anchor for many YouTube Channels, namely Ang Maestro Lectures @Katipunan Channel (Saturdays), Unfinished Revolution (Sundays) and Opinyon Online (Wednesdays) with Ka Mentong Laurel, and Ipa-Rush Kay Paras with former Secretary Jacinto Paras (Tuesdays and Thursdays). His personal vlog is @AdoPaglinawan.

(adolfopaglinawan@yahoo.com)

To purchase any of these books @P899 per copy or P2499 for bundle of 3, please text 0917-336-4366.
This promo includes free delivery by JRS to anywhere in the Philippines.
 

Email: contact@asiancenturyph.com

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/asiancenturyph/

Twitter: https://twitter.com/AsianCenturyPH

Substack:

Also read:

READ: Executive Intelligence Review (EIR) is a weekly newsmagazine founded in 1974 by the American political activist Lyndon LaRouche

Leave a Reply

Trending