Marcos Jr. mimics Washington’s Kleptopolitiks using Weak Laws

 

By Adolfo Quizon Paglinawan

 

Series 36: Forever peace or forever wars?

          The positions of the Philippine claiming sovereignty over features that are not covered by the 1898 Treaty of Paris and the 1900 Treaty of Washington between the United States and Spain, and the 1930 Convention Treaty between the United States and Great Britain, are utterly weak.

          The mother, or basic foundation of all these claims, was 1978 Presidential Decree 1596 that carved a Kalayaan Island Group out of the Spratly Islands, consisting of features, starting with Thitu Island in July 29, 1971 which it later renamed as “Pagasa” or hope.

As I have said, this internal law, was null and void ab initio. From the very beginning,  Thitu Island was not terra nullius. Moreover, an internal or domestic law, cannot supersede international law.

The preamble of the decree was not factual, but a distortion: “Whereas, these areas do not legally belong to any state or nation but, by reason of history, indispensable need, and effective occupation and control established in accordance with the international law…”

As of the 1978 proclamation of the decree, such areas have long been formally returned by Japan to the Republic of China by the Treaty of Taipei in 1952, whose statutory construction was perfected by the Japan-People’s Republic of China Joint Communique in 1972, in fulfillment of the 1943 Cairo and 1945 Potsdam Declarations.

Before the Philippines, Vietnam(as French Indo-China) also has an earlier claim on Thitu which it calls Đảo Thị Tứ which it annexed in 1933. Following World War II,  through actions taken by South Vietnam between 1956 and 1963, Vietnamese naval personnel erected sovereignty steles in the Spratly archipelago.

The decree falsely asserted: “Whereas, while other states have laid claims to some of these areas, their claims have lapsed by abandonment and cannot prevail over that of the Philippines on legal, historical, and equitable grounds.”

During World War II, Imperial Japan placed occupied features in the Paracel and Spratly islands under the administrative jurisdiction of Taiwan (then a Japanese colony) and southern China.

General Douglas MacArthur, in his General Order No. 1 on September 2, 1945, directed Japanese forces in mainland China, Formosa (Taiwan), and French Indochina north of 16° north latitude to surrender to Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek.

Acting under that authority, the ROC government dispatched naval task forces in late 1945 and 1946. Chinese officials accepted the surrender of remaining Japanese garrisons at Yulin Naval Base on Hainan Island and planted stone sovereignty markers on Woody Island (for the Paracels) and Itu Aba/Taiping Island (for the Spratlys), notably naming Thitu as “Zhongye” after the vessel.

A permanent garrison was later setup by the ROC in the island in 1956. It was temporarily vacated in April 1971 when the Taiwanese  soldiers sought shelter in nearby Itu Aba because of strong typhoons.

When they returned in July of the same year, the Armed Forces of the Philippines had already occupied the island, in violation of the United Nations Article 2(4), prohibiting annexation by force.

PD 1596 repeal

The Philippines currently occupies and administers seven high tide elevations (HTEs) or rocks in the Spratly Islands, settling them through occupation of “unoccupied” land, and stationing military personnel, and later establishing a civilian authority.

  • Pag-asa (Thitu)
  • Likas (West York)
  • Lawak (Nanshan)
  • Kota (Loaita)
  • Parola (Northeast Cay)
  • Patag (Flat)
  • Panata (Lankiam Cay)

Using what I coined as “nominalateralism”, the Philippines is in denial that they were acquired by military conquest or seized by force from other nations, even if it used its armed forces to invade the features.

Nominalateralism simply stated is using trifling, insignificant or token factors to leverage other countries across the table.

The Philippines claims presence in two more features, Ayungin (Second Thomas) Shoal and Rizal (Commodore) Reef but they are low-tide elevations not qualified for sovereignty claim.

This notwithstanding, a greatly disturbing truth was uncovered on July 8, 2015 during the first and second day of the first submissions by the Philippine panel to the 2013 Arbitral Tribunal.

 It will be remembered that on January 22, 2013, the Republic of the Philippines instituted arbitral proceedings against the People’s Republic of China, with the Permanent Court of Arbitration serving as registry.

On the first day of the first submissions on July 7, 2015, Judge Rudiger Wolfrum asked Professor Philippe Sands of the Philippine panel who had just made a presentation:

“Professor Sands, on this particular feature, if I am not totally mistaken, there is a reference to this feature in the Presidential Decree 1596 of the Philippines, and I wonder whether you are taking nationally the same approach you are presenting to us at the moment.”

Prof Sands, replied:

“That one I am definitely going to park, and come back to, until I have had a chance to look at the decree. But we have noted the question, and of course we will come back to that…”

On the second day, July 8, Prof. Sands opened by answering questions from the tribunal, with the following salient points:

“In relation, sir, to your second question, a most astute historical question, if we may say — Presidential Decree 1956, which I will refer to as PD 1956, was enacted on 11th June 1978; that is before UNCLOS was adopted, and also six years before the Philippines’ ratification of the Convention on 8th May 1984.

Under Philippine law, as a treaty lawfully entered into by the Philippines, UNCLOS is part of internal law, and it has the same status as national legislation.

And that means, to the extent that PD 1956 might be consistent with UNCLOS, PD 1956 is to be treated as having been effectively repealed by the Philippines’ subsequent ratification of UNCLOS, under the principle of lex posteriori derogat priori.”

Let me repeat that as of 1984, PD 1596 has been “effectively repealed” when we ratified UNCLOS which by Philippine law, has the same status of a national legislation.

Continuing Deception

From that point, the Philippine panel’s continuing presentation reeked of a twisted narrative, which nobody challenged, as the Philippines was the only participant in that arbitration.

Avoiding the possible implications of such as repeal, Prof. Sands quickly issued a rejoinder:

“The Philippines has, however, also enacted domestic legislation in conformity with UNCLOS. On May 10th 2009, the Philippine Congress enacted Republic Act No. 9522, and that defined the archipelagic baselines in conformity with UNCLOS and other purposes.

“Among these other purposes is the characterisation of the Kalayaan Island Group, as constituted under Presidential Decree No. 1956, in conformity with Article 121 of UNCLOS.

“The Supreme Court ruled in that case that the Philippine Congress’s decision to classify the Kalayaan Island Group as a regime of islands under the Republic of the Philippines consistent with Article 121 of UNCLOS: ‘… manifests the Philippine State’s responsible observance of its pacta sunt servanda obligation under UNCLOS …’ 

“In this way, therefore, PD 1956 is to be treated as having been amended by Republic Act 9522 to bring it into conformity with the 1982 Convention, to the extent that there is a conflict with it.”

What a farce!

First the Philippine panel declared the effective repeal of Presidential Decree 1596 as of 1984.

At the next turn, it asserts that the Philippine enacted a domestic law Republic Act 9522 “that defined the archipelagic baselines in conformity with UNCLOS and other purposes.”

That may be truthful, but as to “other purposes”, I sense a misrepresentation being done in front of an international adjudicatory body.

Republic Act 9522 is an amending legislation to update past legislations including Presidential Decree 1596. It reads:

“Section 2. The baseline in the following areas over which the Philippines likewise exercises sovereignty and jurisdiction shall be determined as “Regime of Islands” under the Republic of the Philippines consistent with Article 121 of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS):

“a) The Kalayaan Island Group (KIG) as constituted under Presidential Decree No. 1596.”

If the essential operative feature of P.D. 1596 was its treatment of the KIG as a unified territorial area capable of being enclosed by Philippine baselines, yet that mechanism was incompatible with Article 47 of UNCLOS, the Philippine government’s manifestation before the Arbitral Tribunal, it means that mechanism ceased to have legal effect in 1984.

If the legislature wants to bring back or alter the substance of a repealed statute, it must enact a new law or reenact the provisions independently.

Resurrecting a dead law

I am sorry but the Philippine Congress has no divine powers.

Presidential Decree 1596 was repealed in 1984, and here is a law (RA9522) amending it in 2009 after being dead for 25 years, and another law (RA12064) trying again to resurrect it again in 2024 or 15 years after.

That’s no better than making the Filipino people eat a double-dead pork. 

In Latin this translates to NEMO TENETUR AD IMPOSSIBILE OR IMPOSSIBILIUM NULLA OBLIGATIO EST.

A repealed law is treated as a legal nullity or a “dead law”—it has been completely abrogated and removed from the statute books as if it had never been enacted.

Because there is no longer any active statute left to alter, you cannot amend a repealed law.

  • The Nature of Repeal vs. Amendment: An amendment modifies an existing law while leaving a portion of it standing. A repeal completely extinguishes or abolishes the law.
  • The “Dead Law” Concept: Jurisprudence recognizes that a repealed or expired statute is dead and cannot be resurrected, extended, or amended through a direct amendatory act.
  • General Maxim on Impossibility: Attempting to legally amend a non-existent statute runs contrary to basic statutory logic and the broader legal principle that the law does not require or recognize an impossible act, thus again nemo tenetur ad impossibile or impossibilium nulla obligatio est.

The action of the Supreme Court affirming the constitutionality of the law updating the archipelagic baselines of the Philippines, applies only to amend certain provisions of Republic Act 3046 as amended by Republic Act 5446 because they are still in force.

But the Supreme Court decision, with expired associate justice Antonio Carpio as ponente, overlooked an awkwardly inserted “rider” amending PD1596 for a Kalayaan Island Group originally intended as an “archipelago”, into a “regime of islands” to be consistent with Article 121 of UNCLOS.

It did not only amend a dead law but failed to present coordinates for the respective “islands” when the purpose of RA 9522 was to update baselines.

The Philippine Maritime Zones Act made it more ridiculous. The statement of RA 12064 that it was “amending” Section 1 of PD1596 presents as serious municipal inconsistency as it is erroneously premised that the old PD 1596 regime survived. Congress was making it appear modifying whatever residual operative provision remained, or more controversially, as legislative treatment of a supposedly already-displaced decree as though it remained operative.

This is also why I discern a malicious intention to introduce a legislative gobbledygook because both RAs 9522 and 12064 deliberately retained the term “Kalayaan Island Group” to what they converting onto a new identity as a Kalayaan Regime of Islands (KRI).

That is not transparency.

Rather than piecing together a Frankenstein statute through cross-referenced amendments, passing a dedicated new law gives legislators, the judiciary, and the public a transparent, integrated text to debate and scrutinize from scratch.

In jurisdictions like the Philippines, legal doctrine draws a sharp line between an amendment (modifying specific parts without altering basic principles) and a revision (overhauling the substantial entirety or fundamental plan).

Pushing a foundational change under the guise of a minor amendment often leaves the act vulnerable to being struck down as unconstitutional or ultra vires (beyond powers).

RA 9522 could therefore not revive or amend that extinct legal mechanism in 2009; at most, it should have independently legislated a new UNCLOS-compliant regime for the features it sought to convert from KIG to KRI, in avoidance of ambivalence and in faithfulness to  clarity.

Instead of a patch-work amendment that twists a law into serving a totally different objective, Congress should have chosen to pass a brand-new statute. This cleanly terminates the obsolete purpose and establishes the new mandate without leaving conflicting legal baggage behind.

Claim without a cover

Presidential Decree 1596 was an internal law that created an archipelago within the Spratly Archipelago. Under Article 47 of UNCLOS that changed the definition of an archipelago, the decree posed a violation.

Even Paragraph 574 of the 2016 Arbitral Award categorically emphasized this:

“In any event, however, even the Philippines could not declare archipelagic baselines surrounding the Spratly Islands. Article 47 of the Convention limits the use of archipelagic baselines to circumstances where “within such baselines are included the main islands and an area in which the ratio of the area of the water to the area of the land, including atolls, is between 1 to 1 and 9 to 1.”599 The ratio of water to land in the Spratly Islands would greatly exceed 9:1 under any conceivable system of baselines.

After its repeal, no legislation has been made to independently reconstruct the status of the high tide elevation (HTE) features of the repealed Kalayaan Island Group as a regime of islands.

At the risk of redundancy, its inclusion in RA 9522 was infirmed because it was just treated as an obscure rider.

Worse, no legislation names and identifies the features being enrolled in such a regime, even as they were already classified as “rocks” by the 2016 Arbitral Ruling, which in conformity to UNCLOS are entitled to 12 nautical miles territorial sea.

This limits justification of the entire seven features occupied by the Philippines to only de-facto possession, under the principle of effectivités or effective control since 1971.

But they have no legal cover. Internally or internationally.

The Philippines cannot even invoke the “provisional status quo” China compromise’s with ASEAN states having possessions in the South China Seas when it signed the 2002 Declaration of Conduct because Manila disregarded its bilateral mechanism when it resorted to arbitration in 2013.

This why China’s bottom line now is that I does not recognize any of the Philippine claims in the disputed waters.

Looking back, even the original Presidential Decree 1596 did not name the features, with appropriate individuating descriptions and coordinates.  What it only accomplished was to draw the coordinates of the entire KIG intended to be an archipelago.

“From a point [on the Philippine Treaty Limits] at latitude 7§40′ North and longitude 116§00 East of Greenwich, thence due West along the parallel of 7§40′ N to its intersection with the meridian of longitude 112§10′ E, thence due north along the meridian of 112§10′ E to its intersection with the parallel of 9§00′ N, thence northeastward to the intersection of parallel of 12§00′ N with the meridian of longitude 114§30′ E, thence, due East along the parallel of 12§00′ N to its intersection with the meridian of 118§00′ E, thence, due South along the meridian of longitude 118§00′ E to its intersection with the parallel of 10§00′ N, thence Southwestwards to the point of beginning at 7§40′ N, latitude and 116§00′ E longitude.

As such, the original chart was clumsily drawn and so erroneous because it included features that are occupied or are being claimed by other coastal states.

The same amateur and reckless lawmaking extended to the National Maritime Zones Act that created a ghost “West Philippine Sea” using the repealed Kalayaan Island Group as one of its components.

That is why I called Republic Act 12064 as a stupid law, and repeated the remarks under oath before the TriCom of the Lower House of Congress, at the risk of being held in contempt or detained.

We went to town declaring an arbitral victory the so-called nine-dash line and then at the next turn, we legislated what we have exposed here as defective laws creating a ghost West Philippine Sea.

Yes, the tribunal ultimately held in 2016 that China’s claimed historic rights within the nine-dash line were **without lawful effect insofar as they exceeded the maritime entitlements permitted by UNCLOS but the tribunal expressly said it was not deciding territorial sovereignty or maritime boundary delimitation, which was outside of its jurisdiction.

Because of RA 12064, the Philippines embarked under President Marcos Jr. an aggressive assertion of this so-called West Philippine Sea, which has resulted in the escalation of our conflicts at sea with China.

This is unfortunate because Section 12 of this law, distinctly provides that:

Section 12. Delimitation. – Where the maritime zones defined in this Act overlap with the maritime zones of a neighboring State based on the UNCLOS, the common boundaries shall be determined by agreement with that State in accordance with the relevant principles of delimitation under international law

International law permits a state to establish its maritime zones through national legislation. But a national statute cannot, by itself, settle a maritime boundary with another state. Where overlapping entitlements exist, delimitation requires agreement or an applicable international adjudicatory mechanism (UNCLOS Article 59).

The Philippines used UNCLOS arbitration to establish that maritime entitlements must derive from UNCLOS rather than historic claims, while subsequently using domestic legislation to codify and operationalize its own claimed maritime zones in areas where those zones overlap with claims or potential entitlements of other coastal states.

There is clearly a double standard here, especially when the succeeding section of the national legislation states:

Section 13. Due Regard and Mutual Respect. – The Philippines shall give due regard to the rights and duties of foreign states, and foreign states shall act with due regard to the rights and duties of the Philippines, relative to the maritime zones as provided under this Act, the UNCLOS, and international law.

The issue has become escalatory because as influenced by the United States rules-based order, and not just international law that it invokes as basis, the Philippines has been treating UNCLOS-based maritime entitlements, as though they constitute internationally agreed boundaries with other coastal states. This results to conflict escalation because Philippine maritime entitlements do overlap with the potential entitlements of Vietnam. Malaysia, Indonesia, Brunei and China.

Conclusion

When laws are clear, people can understand their rights and duties, officials apply rules consistently, and society remains predictable and fair.

We cannot properly function in a theatre of ambivalence. . We cannot go to adjudication with weak claims. We cannot go to court with dirty hands.

Before spiking a neighboring country with what we think is wrong with them, we should first put our act together.

The matter of addressing our foreign policy is best left to the Department of Foreign Affairs, not the agency that utilizes American kleptopolitics to feign a leading edge.

In the long run, our senators and congressmen must abandon polemics, and return to their primary mandate of lawmaking, and unknot our disconcerted legal positions, especially with regard to foreign relations.

Senator Rodante Marcoleta was starting to open this can of worms, before he was persecuted by the present vindictive regime filing trumped up criminal suits against him and putting him to jail.

It is already unfortunate that we now have a leadership that prioritizes on the matter of “sovereignty” and protecting the integrity of Philippine territory from foreigners, which only 2% of our people support.

(Curiously, the latest Pulse Asia Survey last September places our most urgent national concern as “controlling inflation” highest at 71%.)

In opening a Summit presently being held in Manila, President Marcos Jr., as exiting rotational chairman, called on the Association of Southeast Asian Nations  for shared commitment to international law and the peaceful settlement of disputes reflected in our actions, including through self-restraint, mutual respect, and practical cooperation.

Does he even know what he is talking about?

Hasn’t he noticed that he is the only one left with the elephant in the room?

To be continued

 

Adolfo Quizon Paglinawan

is former diplomat who served as press attaché and spokesman of the Philippine Embassy in Washington DC and the Philippines’ Permanent Mission to the United Nations in New York from April 1986 to 1993. Presently, he is vice-president for internal affairs of the Asian Century Philippines Institute, a geopolitical analyst, author of books, columnist, a print and broadcast journalist, and a hobby-organic-farmer.

His best sellers, A Problem for Every Solution (2015), a characterization of factors affecting Philippine-China relations, and No Vaccine for a Virus called Racism (2020) a survey of international news attempting to tracing its origins, earned for him an international laureate in the Awards for the Promotion of Philippine-China Understanding in 2021. His third book, The Poverty of Power is now available – a historiography of controversial issues of spanning 36 years leading to the Demise of the Edsa Revolution and the Forthcoming Rise of a Philippine Phoenix.

Today he is anchor for many YouTube Channels, namely Ang Maestro Lectures @Katipunan Channel (Saturdays), Unfinished Revolution (Sundays) and Opinyon Online (Wednesdays) with Ka Mentong Laurel, and Ipa-Rush Kay Paras with former Secretary Jacinto Paras (Tuesdays and Thursdays). His personal vlog is @AdoPaglinawan.

(adolfopaglinawan@yahoo.com)

To purchase any of these books @P899 per copy or P2499 for bundle of 3, please text 0917-336-4366.
This promo includes free delivery by JRS to anywhere in the Philippines.
 

Email: contact@asiancenturyph.com

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/asiancenturyph/

Twitter: https://twitter.com/AsianCenturyPH

Substack:

Also read:

READ: Executive Intelligence Review (EIR) is a weekly newsmagazine founded in 1974 by the American political activist Lyndon LaRouche

Leave a Reply

Trending